Just Can't Get Enough
Friday, September 28, 2007 at 02:33PM Who else but Get The Picture:
A couple of days ago, I linked to a story in USA Today about how the NCAA was looking to expand the playoffs for 1-AA football to 18 games.
Well, according to the same paper, it looks like the NCAA is just getting started.
The championship and competition cabinet last week forwarded a proposal to the NCAA’s board of directors to enlarge the current 16-team field to 18 beginning in 2008. Cabinet chair Carolyn Femovich says that is the first step toward a field of 24 in the near future.
“I think that’s the ideal number we’re shooting for,” says Femovich, executive director of the I-AA Patriot League. “The cabinet heard loud and clear that future expansion could be both warranted and necessary to provide access to all of our qualified conferences and members.”
In case you’re wondering, that’s 24 schools out of 120 total in Division 1-AA. For now, of course…
Got that Plus One fans? It doesn't stop there. This is bureaucracy we're talking about here, and interests who are at a trough. Once you create something, it just grows and expands and changes course from its limited intended purpose. Call it "mission creep", call it bugaboo, call it whatever - it sucks.
Those of you quibbling over a four-team playoff or an eight team or a sixteen ... I'm not sure that you understand that whatever you think is right, the future course is already set for massive expansion. You and I may disagree about not having a playoff versus having an eight-team framework but in the end we'll both lose because that beast won't stay in its cage.
The only power here in having a say about the direction of the sport is in saying "yes" or "no". Count me as a strong "no".
CFR |
6 Comments | 





Reader Comments (6)
Beginning-1969: There was the NL & AL and the winner of each league met in the World Series.
1969-1993: Each league was broken down into 2 divisions and a championship series was played within each league before the championship series winners met in the World Series
1995-Present: There are now 3 division with 1 wild card.
That's going from 2 to 4 to 8 teams in the playoffs and baseball has been the SLOWEST sport of any to go through changes considering how many purists there are.
Given how "PLAYOFFS CRAZY" the average american sports fan is, how long before a "PLUS 1" goes to a 4-team playoff? Or better yet how long before every BCS conference wants at least 1 person in the tournament giving at least 6, but since that's an odd number, how about 8 teams? Well now all of a sudden some subjectivity comes into play with teams #7 and #8 and don't forget your mid majors like Boise State last year or TCU, Hawaii or other teams like that who'll feel like they'll need another taste.
How long before it's 12 teams with 4 teams getting a first round bye? Wait a minute! How can we discriminate against different conference champions? We need at least 6 1st round byes so need at least 20 more teams in the playoffs keep it all even and working out.
And it's not just sports. For goodness sakes, look at the federal government or ANY human resource department at a company. It's a slippery slope into hell is what it is.
If you're going to be anti-playoffs that's fine; you've made very good points in that vein in the past. However, warning of playoff creep is not going to get you very far against those critical of bowls because that one solidly goes both ways.
And what's to say a longer playoff is bad? The larger the sample size of games, the more likely you are to have an accurate result.
Your post on the expansion of the I-AA postseason brought gales of laughter around the office. You truly are a gifted comedic writer. Last year, 64 I-A schools competed in 32 bowls.
And you "complain" about soon 24 I-AA schools making the postseason. That's comedy gold, Jerry.
This post represents one of your better comedic efforts. A few of us nearly peed ourselves while reading your post.
We understand that you need to discuss other things besides the bowl system. Understand, though, your best comedic material comes from your "defense" of the bowl system.
Keep up the effort. By the way, a couple of the guys, wants to know if you write for Conan or Letterman. I am going with Kimmel.
CFR isn't defending the bowls. He's defending the regular season.